Australistan
The debate over the RU486 drug has really gone a bit crazy.
Exhibit A: Danna Vale
"I've actually read in The Daily Telegraph where a certain imam from the Lakemba mosque actually said that Australia's going to be a Muslim nation in 50 years' time."
"I didn't believe him at the time, but you know when you actually look at the birth rates and when you look at the fact that we are aborting ourselves almost out of existence by 100,000 abortions every year - and that's on a guesstimate."
"You multiply that by 50 years - that's 5 million potential Australians we won't have."
There are several problems here.
1) "I've actually read..." means "I saw somewhere that someone who sounds important* said it. So it must be true."
2) The subtle distinction being made between 'us' and 'them'. We are aborting ourselves... she cries - implying, of course, that 'they' aren't.
3) 100,000 abortions every year. Is that really the expected figure for the next fifty years? Or are we just fear-mongering?
4) Even if it were true, what's the big deal? Why would more Muslims be a bad thing? What exactly are you saying about Islam, Danna?
5) And this one's not entirely on the topic, but weren't there race riots in Danna Vale's electorate barely two months ago?
Exhibit B: Jackie Kelly
"Ms Jackie Kelly said the lack of babies for adoption in Australia was leading to "a trade in babies" from overseas.
She said the West was "plundering" the developing world for children. This led to social problems in the countries from which the children were removed.
"You create a trade in babies which leads to some tragic decisions for a woman overseas," Ms Kelly said.
"You've got an option of selling a kid sort of on the sly to support your own children".
The West had to look to itself to solve its problems, she said.
The West has to look to itself to solve its problems. Exactly. We shouldn't have to plunder the third world for unwanted children. We could make our own home-grown unwanted children right here. We should be stimulating our own economy in 'baby trading'. And why stop there? If we produce enough unwanted babies, we could start exporting them ourselves.
When you remember that this debate is about whether a government minister should determine if a drug is safe, or whether it should be left to an expert committee, the whole thing becomes more and more bizarre.
* No insult intended to the imam of Lakemba mosque, Sheikh Shady Alsuleiman (no puns please). If Sheikh Shady happens to be reading this, please be aware that I'm sure you are a wise person, and that your statements could easily have been made in a proper and commonsensical context. I am aware that I don't actually know what that context was. The point is, I bet Danna doesn't know either.
The song that got annoyingly stuck in my head today:
An old 'Play School' tune that goes:
Put a spot over here,
and a spot over there.
Put a spot in your ear,
and a spot in your hair...

